Do you ever have one of those evenings you enjoy so much that you can’t wait to do it again but inevitably the second time is a disappointment? Were your expectations too high because of the initial experience? Or if the first experience had been more like the second, would you not have been dying to repeat it?
Saturday Felony Joyride and I decided to go back to Perbacco. We died and went to pig heaven after our first Perbacco experience. I couldn’t wait to go back. As FJ said, he never wanted to leave. We used going to see Sam Shepard’s “Curse of the Starving Class” at A.C.T. as our excuse to go back. It was really just an excuse. I declared in the car that if Perbacco were open during the day, we would drive straight there and skip the play. FJ concurred.
It turned out to be a play not to be skipped. Talk about dysfunctional family.
But back to the pig. We arrived at Perbacco promptly when the door opened and immediately ordered martinis with these fabulous olives that the restaurant makes in-house. I don’t know what they’re called, but they’re a very vibrant green color and aren’t briney. Instead they’re buttery. A perfect compliment to Tanqueray 10. (I usually have a twist rather than olives because your standard olives just ruin the taste of good gin.)
We were ecstatic to see Pig Boy still doing his salumi magic behind the bar but a bit disappointed that our bartender from last time no longer works there. The new bartender was nice enough (he gave me extra olives for my ‘tini) but the service was less than stellar. Inattentive is more like it.
We started with the salumi sampler platter which was just as fabulous as we’d remembered. And the always-awesome Pig Boy had some “face meat” waiting for us. We didn’t even have to ask. He remembered! We were also given a very generous ahi appetizer on-the-house. Next we did a squid salad. It was OK. Squid is always, well, chewy, and this was no exception. Then we had a wonderful agnolotti filled with roasted veal.
Then it was time for entrees. The quail that we went crazy over last time was no longer on the menu which we thought was a good thing because we wanted to try new dishes. Boy was that a mistake. Both of our entrees were supremely disappointing. In fact, if I was basing my opinion of the restaurant solely on those two dishes, I would never go back. I had lamb chops with braised chard and some sort of large beans. I asked for the lamb medium-rare. It was overcooked. There were only about 5 beans on my plate. Granted they were large beans, but come on, I love beans! And then there was a giant pile of chard. Chard is good but shouldn’t be the focal point of a dish which this clearly became since a) there was so much of it and b) the lamb was overcooked and disappointing.
FJ’s entree was not any better - big-eyed tuna. Granted I have zero experience with big-eyed tuna but isn’t all tuna supposed to be rare? Perhaps I’m just used to seared ahi. This was more like medium-well big-eye. It was also seriously lacking in salt. I honestly cannot even remember what else came with the dish.
The great thing about San Francisco being a city of restaurants is that if you are having a bad experience at one, you can get up and go to another. This is exactly what we did. We left Perbacco and went over to Cafe Majestic (scene of the dinner for the most recent anniversary of my 27th birthday) and had the cheese course followed by foie gras ice cream! Oh, and plenty of wine. As we sat down, they were just starting to play “All About Eve.” (They always show old movies in the bar.) FJ declared that we wouldn’t be there until the end of the movie. Next thing we knew, Phoebe was taking a bow in front of Eve’s bedroom mirror.
Moral of the story: go to Perbacco for martinis, salumi, and pasta. Skip the entrees. (Oh, and don’t let a bad experience ruin your night. Get up and go somewhere else!)